THE ongoing reforms in the nation’s banks may soon be dogged by a fresh
litigation, as a group of shareholders has threatened to drag the Central Bank
of Nigeria (CBN) to court, over alleged unilateral merger and acquisitions
exercise of the financial institutions.
Also, the stakeholders, under the aegis of Independent Shareholders Association
of Nigeria (ISAN) have concluded plans to formally petition President Goodluck
Jonathan ahead of the legal suit, over the matter.
CBN governor, Sanusi Lamido Sanusi, recently disclosed in London, United Kingdom
that 10 of the current 24 banks in the country would merge by end of this month,
while industry sources indicated that the number of the financial institutions
may eventually shrink to 15, under a merger/acquisition scheme already scripted
by the apex bank.
Indeed, some of the “rescued banks” have unfolded plans to enter into
negotiations with certain undisclosed investors, while a few Memorandum of
Understanding (MOUs) had even been reached by a few of the banks, with
prospective buyers.
But ISAN’s national co-ordinator, Sunny Nwosu, told The
Guardian yesterday that CBN’s
moves would be challenged in the court, “as they are statutorily illegal, due to
non-consultations with shareholders, who are the owners of the banks”,
However, “before we file the suit, we would send a petition to President
Goodluck Jonathan to see if he could call the CBN governor to order”.
Nwosu pointed out that already, “Access Bank Plc has been planned to buy over
the bigger Intercontinental Bank Plc, through an MOU drafted and signed by two
CBN lawyers, which has further thrown up immorality issues in the deal”.
According to him, “the plan to sell the banks’ shares to pre-determined
investors, from our intelligence sources, had been concluded earlier, with
intention to favour certain investors close to CBN leadership.
“The situational factor surrounding the plan would normally elicit concerns from
all those that are interested in transparency and rule of law, as the moves
being made so far by CBN have been shrouded in utmost secrecy.”
“All we’ve been hearing have been one-sided valuations of the banks’ assets by
CBN appointed financial advisers, without reference to the shareholders. We
even had information that the banks are being made to pay for the services of
those consultants.
“From all indications, the same CBN appointed managements of the so-called
rescued banks have been declaring the banks as inadequately capitalized, without
independent verifications by shareholders. Where then is the transparency in
the whole process?
Nwosu said that the recently established Assets Management Company of Nigeria (AMCON)
has been surreptously engaged to discount the assets of some of these banks,
“preparatory to selling their respective shares for peanuts”.
Besides, he stressed that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has been
shying away from making positive intervention, which would ensure adherence to
laid-down procedures in shares’ acquisition, under the present bids for the
banks.
“Under the prevailing regulations, the shareholders should be allowed to source
for suitable and compatible investors, where the need arises and we are not sure
there is need for current shopping for investors by CBN, for the banks.
“Indeed, if there is any capital shortfall that requires the banks to
recapitalise, both the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) and Banks and
other Financial Institutions Act (BOFIA) require all shareholders to have the
first right to recapitalise the banks.
“In doing this, the shareholders, at the emergency general meeting would mandate
the board and management of the concerned bank to script the necessary moves and
not the other way round where investors are being imposed on them by CBN.”He
added: “We find the role being played by AMCON as anomalous and could threaten
the legal firmament of the entire financial system”, explaining that beside
unsavory discounting of banks’ shares, “AMCON is not supposed to be a voting
partner in the system as this is a direct and illegal move to reduce the powers
of shareholders”. Nwosu disclosed that plans to make Access Bank to buy over
Intercontinental Bank is most unfortunate and would be resisted by shareholders.
“It is amusing that someone with small throat is being made to swallow a bigger
object. When the object has been swallowed, there would obviously be some
braises on such small throat, “making philosophical reference to Access Bank’s
bid for Intercontinental Bank. He asked: “Why don’t you allow the bank, through
the shareholders, to ‘toast’ each other before courting so that their respective
compatibilities would be assessed. Why does CBN want to destroy one bank or
discount its shares to make it cheaper in the market in favour of pre-determined
investors. An official of Intercontinental Bank, who spoke on condition of
anonymity, declined to confirm Access Bank’s bid for his bank, even as he
affirmed that an MOU was earlier reached by both banks for an acquisition deal.
“We are still looking for investors. The fact that we reached an MOU with
Access Bank does not confirm that we have consented to the terms of a buyer.
The exercise is ongoing and we implore everybody to exercise patience till the
deal has been consummated”, he said. Currently, the CBN was still keeping mum
over the number of foreign concerns interested in Nigerian banks. Already, South
Africa’s FirstRand, has expressed interest in buying one of the nine rescued
banks. “We did register interest in that process. I’m not able to mention which
bank, but we certainly registered our interest. We are looking at opportunities,
especially given the reforms taking place driven by the Central Bank of
Nigeria,” Sizwe Nxasana FirstRand’s Managing Director, Sizwe Nxasama said
recently. The CBN had asked for potential bidders to register their interest in
the troubled banks by mid-December to test the enthusiasm for acquisitions. A
report by the Bank of America, Merrill Lynch published recently, revealed that a
number of South African banks, have continued to express interest in Nigeria’s
banking sector. “A number of South African banks have expressed an interest in
acquiring a stake, in one of the Nigerian banks. At a recent meeting with Johan
Burger, Chief Operating Officer of the FirstRand Group, he described the
situation in Nigeria at the moment as a once in a life time opportunity.” The
Head of Corporate Communications of CBN, Mohammed Abdullahi, recently confirmed
in a media report that stated “discussions are going on already, expressions of
interests have been received between the banks, the financial advisers we
appointed for them, some organisations and individuals that have expressed
interest,” without giving further details. By the end of September, nine of the
banks made provisions in excess of N2.2 trillion for loan losses. Potential
investors are anxious to see how quickly an AMCON can soak up the bad debts and
make the banks attractive.